The 6 Best Tenant Screening Services for Landlords (2026)
Tenant screening is the highest-leverage $30 you'll ever spend as a landlord. One bad tenant can cost you months of rent and an eviction; one solid report keeps that from happening. The six services below are the ones independent landlords actually use in 2026 — ranked by how often they come up in landlord forums, review counts, and practical usefulness for small portfolios. All six pull credit, criminal, and eviction data; what separates them is who pays, how fast the report lands, and how much friction the applicant faces.
A quick pricing note up front: screening prices change, and most services run frequent promotions. Figures below are typical published ranges as of early 2026 — verify current pricing before you budget.
1. TransUnion SmartMove — the industry default
SmartMove is TransUnion's direct-to-landlord screening product, and it's the one most landlords have at least tried. You send the applicant an email invitation, they verify their own identity and enter sensitive info directly (you never handle their Social Security number), and the report lands in your dashboard.
What you get: Credit report with score (TransUnion data), criminal background check, eviction history, plus "Income Insights" estimating income-to-rent ratio on higher-tier packages.
Cost: Landlord-paid or applicant-paid options; packages typically run ~$25–$40 per screen depending on the bundle. Applicant-paid is the most popular setup because it keeps your screening cost at zero.
Turnaround: Minutes in most cases — one of the fastest options on this list.
Minimum requirements: Here's the catch landlords complain about most: SmartMove requires landlord identity verification before you can run reports. Expect to verify your identity (including your Social Security number) during account setup. If you'd rather not hand your SSN to a screening company, pick a different service.
Honest drawback: The identity-verification hurdle plus an interface that hasn't aged gracefully. Some landlords also find the upsells between tiers annoying. But on report quality and speed, it's the benchmark everyone else is compared to.
2. RentPrep — best when you want a human involved
RentPrep is the veteran of this list, and its differentiator is people: their team manually reviews every report for accuracy, and their FCRA-certified screeners will walk you through what a borderline report actually means. In a world of instant automated reports, the human layer catches false positives — wrong-person criminal hits are a real problem in automated screening.
What you get: Credit, criminal, and eviction history with human verification; their screeners can explain findings on a call instead of leaving you to interpret raw data.
Cost: Landlord-paid, tiered pricing — typically ~$20–$35 per screen depending on the package, as of early 2026 (verify current pricing). No applicant-paid option, so budget this as a cost of filling the unit.
Turnaround: Hours to a day. Manual verification is the trade-off for accuracy — if you're screening in a competitive market where speed matters, this can feel slow.
Minimum requirements: Standard account setup with basic credentialing; no unusual identity hoops compared to SmartMove.
Honest drawback: Speed. You're trading instant results for accuracy and support, and landlords who screen five applicants in a weekend will feel the difference. The landlord-paid-only model also stings when you're screening high volumes.
3. MyRental (CoreLogic) — the data giant's landlord product
CoreLogic is one of the largest aggregators of property and public-records data in the country, and MyRental is its product aimed at independent landlords. It's less famous than SmartMove but pulls from deep data sources, including its eviction and criminal databases.
What you get: Credit, criminal, and eviction reports with decision-point style scoring to help interpret results. The reports are thorough — CoreLogic's data depth is genuinely a selling point.
Cost: Landlord-paid or applicant-paid options available; typically ~$25–$40 per screen depending on configuration (verify current pricing).
Turnaround: Minutes to a few hours for most reports.
Minimum requirements: Account registration with standard landlord credentialing; the setup is a bit more form-heavy than consumer-grade competitors.
Honest drawback: Brand recognition cuts both ways — applicants are more familiar with TransUnion-branded reports, and MyRental's interface can feel dated and upsell-heavy. It's a strong report wrapped in a forgettable experience.
4. Avail tenant screening — best if you want it bundled
Avail (the free property-management platform from Realtor.com's parent company) runs screening through TransUnion as part of its application workflow. The big advantage: screening isn't a separate tool you log into — it's built into the application the tenant already fills out, so nothing gets lost in email.
What you get: TransUnion credit, criminal, and eviction reports, delivered inside Avail's application dashboard alongside the tenant's application answers.
Cost: Applicant-paid — typically ~$30 per report as of early 2026 (verify current pricing). Your cost: $0.
Turnaround: Minutes to a few hours, depending on how quickly the applicant completes their portion.
Minimum requirements: You need an Avail landlord account (free). No special landlord identity verification beyond standard account setup.
Honest drawback: You only get Avail's screening if you use Avail for applications. If you're not on the platform, it's not a standalone option — and landlords who want raw, maximally detailed reports sometimes find the bundled version less granular than running SmartMove directly. (Full review: Avail Review 2026.)
5. Zillow rental applications — the applicant-friendly option
Zillow's screening is built into its rental application: the applicant pays one fee, completes one application, and can submit it to multiple Zillow listings within a 30-day window. For applicants, this is the best deal in screening — for landlords, it means reports arrive with zero setup.
What you get: TransUnion-based credit, criminal, and eviction screening reports, shared with you through the Zillow listing dashboard.
Cost: Applicant-paid — one fee (historically ~$30–$35, good for 30 days across multiple applications). Landlords pay nothing.
Turnaround: Reports are available as soon as the applicant submits; often same-day.
Minimum requirements: You need a rental listing on Zillow. No landlord identity verification beyond your Zillow account.
Honest drawback: You're working inside Zillow's walled garden. The applicant controls which reports they share, the reports are less customizable than running your own screen, and you're tied to Zillow's listing ecosystem. Great for volume in competitive markets; less ideal if you want full control over the screening process.
6. Apartments.com (Cozy) screening — the simple classic
Cozy was one of the first free landlord platforms, and its screening tools live on under Apartments.com. It's straightforward: credit and background checks with the option for the applicant or the landlord to pay.
What you get: Credit, criminal, and eviction screening reports through the Apartments.com landlord dashboard.
Cost: Landlord-paid or applicant-paid; historically ~$25–$30 per screen (verify current pricing — pricing has shifted through the Cozy-to-Apartments.com transition).
Turnaround: Minutes to hours.
Minimum requirements: An Apartments.com landlord account; standard setup, nothing unusual.
Honest drawback: The Cozy brand sunset means the product is living inside a much larger corporate platform now, and some longtime users say the screening experience has lost the simplicity that made Cozy popular. It works, but it's no longer anyone's first choice — which is why it sits at #6.
Side-by-side comparison
| Service | Credit | Criminal | Eviction | Typical cost | Who pays | Turnaround |
|---|
| TransUnion SmartMove | Yes | Yes | Yes | ~$25–$40 | Either | Minutes |
|---|
| RentPrep | Yes | Yes | Yes | ~$20–$35 | Landlord | Hours–1 day |
|---|
| MyRental (CoreLogic) | Yes | Yes | Yes | ~$25–$40 | Either | Minutes–hours |
|---|
| Avail (TransUnion) | Yes | Yes | Yes | ~$30 | Applicant | Minutes–hours |
|---|
| Zillow applications | Yes | Yes | Yes | ~$30–$35 (30-day) | Applicant | Same-day |
|---|
| Apartments.com (Cozy) | Yes | Yes | Yes | ~$25–$30 | Either | Minutes–hours |
|---|
Prices are typical published ranges as of early 2026 — verify current pricing before committing.
How to stay FCRA-compliant when you screen
Screening reports are consumer reports under the Fair Credit Reporting Act, and getting this wrong can cost you far more than a bad tenant. Two rules cover 90% of landlord risk:
Get written consent before you run anything. Every service above bakes this into the applicant flow — the tenant authorizes the check when they complete their portion. If you ever run a report outside these platforms, get a signed, standalone authorization first. Don't bury it in the lease; the FCRA wants it separate and conspicuous.
Send adverse action notices when you reject (or charge more) based on a report. If a screening report is any part of why you deny an application — or approve with a higher deposit — you must send the applicant an adverse action notice naming the reporting agency, stating you didn't make the decision yourself from their data alone, and informing them of their right to a free copy of the report and to dispute it. Most screening services provide a template; use it. Document everything.
Two more habits that keep you safe: apply the same screening criteria to every applicant (this is also a fair-housing requirement — see our fair housing guide for landlords), and store reports securely and dispose of them properly — credit reports contain Social Security numbers, and leaving them in an unlocked filing cabinet or an unencrypted email thread is asking for trouble.
FAQ
Can I charge the applicant for the screening fee?
Usually yes — applicant-paid screening is the industry norm, and most states allow you to pass the actual cost through. But several states cap the amount or require an itemized receipt, and a few restrict application fees outright. Check your state's rules before charging; our state landlord-tenant law guides cover the key fee rules.
What if the applicant already has a recent report from another service?
You can accept it, but most landlords re-run their own screen anyway — you can't verify a PDF someone emailed you, and forged reports are a real scam. A reasonable compromise: accept reports run through a recognized service within the last 30 days (Zillow's shareable application is built for exactly this), and re-screen everyone else.
Do I need to screen every adult who will live in the unit?
Yes. Every adult occupant (18+) should complete an application and screening, not just the primary leaseholder. Unscreened occupants are one of the most common ways problem tenancies start — and your insurance and lease assume you know who's living there.
Can I deny an applicant based on their credit score alone?
Legally you can, as long as your criteria are applied consistently to all applicants and you send the required adverse action notice. Practically, a single number is a blunt instrument — eviction history and income-to-rent ratio are more predictive. Set written criteria in advance (e.g., minimum score, no evictions in 5 years, income 3x rent) and apply them the same way every time. For what to actually look for, see how to screen tenants and tenant screening red flags.
See also: Tenant Screening Services Compared 2026, Avail Review 2026.
Practical Landlord is reader-supported. When you sign up for services through links on this site, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.