Best Home Warranty Companies for Landlords (2026)
- Quick comparison
- 1. Choice Home Warranty — best for low service fees
- 2. First American Home Warranty — best for coverage depth
- 3. American Home Shield — best for contractor network
When you own rental properties, every service call eats into your cash flow. A broken furnace in January or a dead AC in July can turn a good month into a bad one — and if you're managing multiple doors, those surprises compound fast. A home warranty plan for each of your rentals caps that repair risk at a predictable monthly cost plus a flat service fee per claim.
But not all home warranty companies treat landlords well. Some restrict the number of properties per account, some pile on exclusions that matter specifically for rentals (tenant damage, lack of maintenance), and claim caps vary wildly between plans. We compared the four most landlord-relevant home warranty companies on the criteria that actually matter to property owners: multi-property coverage, service call fees, per-claim caps, and landlord-relevant exclusions.
If you're scaling from one door to several, warranty strategy shifts: instead of hunting for the single "best" plan, you want a provider whose per-claim costs stay low and whose claims process doesn't make you or your tenant wait. The table below gives you the at-a-glance view; the sections that follow dig into how each company fits a landlord portfolio specifically.
Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. If you click through and sign up, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you — it helps us keep publishing free landlord guides.
Affiliate disclosure: some links in this article are affiliate links — using them may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Read our full affiliate disclosure for how that works.
Quick comparison
| Choice Home Warranty | First American Home Warranty | American Home Shield | Select Home Warranty | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best for | Landlords who want the lowest service fees | Longest track record, flexible plans | Largest contractor network | Budget-friendly plans with free extras |
| Service call fee | $65–$100 (depending on plan) | $65–$100 | $100–$125 | $60–$100 |
| Per-claim cap | Up to $3,000 per covered item | Up to $5,000 per covered item (varies by plan) | Up to $2,000–$5,000 per covered item (varies by plan) | Up to $2,000 per covered item |
| Multi-property coverage | One contract per property; discount-free stacking | One plan per property | One plan per property | One plan per property |
| Plans | Basic, Total | Basic Plan, Builder's Plan, Premier Plan | ShieldEssential, ShieldPlus, ShieldComplete | Bronze Care, Silver Care, Gold Care |
| Standout perk | Low service fees; fast claims | Covers unknown pre-existing conditions on Premier | Roof leak coverage on top tier | Free roof leak coverage on every plan |
Note: plan names, fees, and caps change — always confirm the current terms on the company's site before buying.
1. Choice Home Warranty — best for low service fees
Choice Home Warranty's pitch for landlords: per-claim costs stay predictable with a flat $100 service fee per claim, and the claims process is built for speed — you can file online or by phone 24/7, which matters when a tenant reports a breakdown at 10 PM.
Landlord pros:
- Service fees from $65 — among the lowest in the industry, so each claim hurts less.
- Two simple plans (Basic and Total) make it easy to pick the right coverage level per property; Total covers major systems like HVAC, plumbing, and electrical.
- 24/7 claims filing by phone or online — handy when tenants report issues outside business hours.
- Current promo: $50 OFF + 1st month FREE when you sign up through their site.
- Covers major appliances (refrigerator, dishwasher, washer/dryer) on both plans — big for furnished or appliance-supplied rentals.
Landlord cons:
- Per-item claim cap of up to $3,000 is lower than First American's top-tier cap — check the cap against the replacement cost of your oldest HVAC unit.
- Like every warranty company, it won't cover problems caused by tenant misuse or lack of maintenance, so keep your maintenance log current.
- Each property needs its own contract; no portfolio-wide master agreement.
If low per-claim costs matter most to your numbers, compare plans and current promos across providers. For a deeper breakdown, read our full Choice Home Warranty review and our Choice Home Warranty cost breakdown.
2. First American Home Warranty — best for coverage depth
First American has been in the warranty business for decades and is known for broader coverage on its top plans. Its Premier Plan covers unknown pre-existing conditions — a genuinely useful feature for landlords who buy older rental properties and can't be sure what's already wearing out behind the walls.
Landlord pros:
- Per-item caps up to $5,000 on higher-tier plans — the best ceiling in this roundup, useful for aging HVAC systems in value-add properties.
- Premier Plan's coverage of unknown pre-existing conditions reduces the "was it already broken?" disputes that landlords dread.
- Three plan tiers (Basic, Builder's, Premier) let you tier coverage by property — budget plan on the new-build unit, Premier on the 1960s bungalow.
Landlord cons:
- Service fees run $65–$100, slightly higher on average than Choice's low end.
- Premium pricing on the Premier Plan — run the numbers against your per-door maintenance budget.
- No direct landlord portfolio product; you manage one contract per property like everyone else.
3. American Home Shield — best for contractor network
American Home Shield runs the largest contractor network of any home warranty company, which means faster dispatch in most markets — a real advantage when a tenant is without heat and the clock is ticking. Its top-tier ShieldComplete plan adds roof leak coverage, and all plans allow you to request your own contractor in some cases.
Landlord pros:
- Largest pro network in the industry — usually the fastest path to a technician at the door.
- ShieldComplete covers roof leaks, a common and expensive landlord headache.
- Optional add-ons (pool, spa, septic) matter for landlords with amenity-heavy single-family rentals.
Landlord cons:
- Service fees of $100–$125 are the highest here — that adds up fast across multiple claims per year.
- Per-item caps of $2,000–$5,000 vary by plan, and the lower tiers cap out well below a full HVAC replacement.
- Online reviews skew more mixed than competitors; read recent ones for your market before committing.
4. Select Home Warranty — best for budget-friendly extras
Select Home Warranty competes on price and freebies: every plan includes free roof leak coverage, plus extras like free rekeying service — small perks that landlords actually use between tenants. If you're covering several doors and want to keep the annual premium low, Select is worth a quote.
Landlord pros:
- Free roof leak coverage on all plans, not just the top tier.
- Free rekeying service is genuinely useful during tenant turnovers.
- Service fees start around $60 — competitive with Choice.
Landlord cons:
- Per-item cap of $2,000 is the lowest in this roundup — fine for appliances, tight for major systems.
- Smaller contractor network than American Home Shield, which can mean slower dispatch in some markets.
- Younger company with a thinner review history; vet it carefully.
How to pick the right home warranty for your rentals
Match the plan to the property, not the portfolio. Your 2019 build and your 1978 duplex don't need the same coverage. Tier your plans by property age and system condition — that's the single biggest lever on cost.
Do the service-fee math. A $125 service fee on three claims a year is $375 per door before the premium. On a tight-cash-flow rental, the difference between a $65 and $125 fee compounds across your whole portfolio. For the cheapest per-claim option, compare current pricing across providers.
Check the cap against your most expensive system. A $2,000 per-item cap doesn't help much if your HVAC replacement runs $6,000. Pull the age and model of each property's furnace and AC before you buy, and choose a plan whose caps cover the likely repair (not replacement) cost.
Read the rental-specific exclusions. Every company on this list excludes damage from tenant misuse and pre-existing conditions you knew about (except First American's Premier, which covers unknown ones). A home warranty is a service contract for mechanical breakdowns from normal wear and tear — it is not insurance, and it covers breakdowns only, not property damage or liability.
Know when a warranty doesn't make sense. If a property's systems are brand new and under manufacturer warranty, or if you self-manage with a reliable handyman who charges less than the service fee per visit, the premium may not pay back. Warranties earn their keep on properties with aging-but-functional systems — the 10-to-20-year-old furnace or water heater that's likely to need a mid-life repair, not a full replacement.
Keep maintenance records. Denied claims most often trace back to poor maintenance documentation. Keep dated records of HVAC servicing, filter changes, and water heater flushes for every door — if a claim is questioned, that paper trail is your leverage. If you want to know whether the whole thing pencils out, read our analysis in is a home warranty worth it for landlords.
The verdict
For comparison: Choice Home Warranty combines low service fees, simple plans, and 24/7 claims. For a head-to-head on the two most popular options, see Choice Home Warranty vs First American.
First American takes second for landlords with older properties, thanks to the best per-item caps and Premier's unknown pre-existing condition coverage.
American Home Shield is the pick when dispatch speed matters most — biggest network, fastest technician at the door — but watch the higher service fees.
Select Home Warranty is the budget play: lowest premiums and free roof-leak coverage on every plan, with the tradeoff of a $2,000 per-item cap.
Whichever plan you pick, it only earns its premium if you track it like a contract: our Home Warranty Service-Call & Claim Log ($14.95) keeps a register of every plan's premium, service-call fee, and coverage cap, logs each claim and denial (with an appeal tracker), and does the per-plan math — fees paid vs. dollars covered — down to a RENEW / SHOP / DROP flag at renewal time.
FAQs
Can a landlord buy one home warranty plan for multiple rental properties?
No — all four companies require a separate contract per property. There is no portfolio-wide master plan on the market from these providers. Budget for one premium per door, and tier coverage by each property's age.
Is a home warranty tax deductible for landlords?
Generally yes — home warranty premiums on rental properties are typically treated as a deductible rental expense, the same as maintenance and repairs. Confirm with your tax professional for your situation.
Will a home warranty cover damage my tenant caused?
No. Every home warranty company excludes damage from misuse, abuse, or neglect — including tenant-caused damage. They cover mechanical breakdowns from normal wear and tear. That's why tenant screening and a documented maintenance routine matter as much as the warranty itself. If a tenant breaks a covered appliance, the repair cost falls to you (or comes out of the security deposit, per your lease terms).