2026-09-26 · 10 min read

Innago vs AppFolio 2026: Free vs. Premium Property Management Software

Innago and AppFolio sit at opposite ends of the property management software market. Innago costs landlords nothing and targets small independent owners. AppFolio charges per unit and targets professional managers with dozens or hundreds of doors. The question isn't which is "better" — it's which one matches your portfolio.

This is a head-to-head on pricing, rent collection, screening, accounting, maintenance, and fit. For Innago's full standalone breakdown, see our Innago review; for how Innago stacks up against the other free option, read Avail vs Innago.

The short version

	Innago	AppFolio

Landlord cost	$0 — no subscription, no per-unit fee	Per-unit monthly pricing (typically ~$1.50/unit/mo with a monthly minimum)

Designed for	1–50 units, DIY landlords	~50+ units, professional managers

Rent collection	ACH, autopay, auto late fees	ACH, autopay, bulk rent payments, more payment options

Screening	Built in, applicant-paid (~$30)	Built in, more report options

Accounting	Basic income/expense tracking	Full general ledger, bank rec, 1099s, owner distributions

Maintenance	Tenant requests, basic tracking	Full work-order system, vendor management, dispatch

Leasing	Listings, applications, e-sign leases	Listings plus AI leasing assistant, automated showings

Support	Email/community, limited for free users	Dedicated support, onboarding, training

Bottom line: under ~20 units, Innago does everything you need for free and AppFolio is overkill you'll pay hundreds a month for. Over ~50 units with staff, owners, and complex accounting, AppFolio earns its fee and Innago will feel thin. The 20–50 unit range is where the decision gets interesting — details below.

Pricing: $0 vs. four figures a year

Innago: $0. No monthly fee, no per-unit charge, no feature paywall on the core product. Innago makes money the way free landlord software typically does: applicant-paid screening fees (around $30 per applicant as of early 2026) and margins on payment processing. You will never get an Innago invoice.

AppFolio: per-unit, with minimums. AppFolio's pricing is per unit per month — typically in the neighborhood of $1.50/unit/month for the core residential product, with a monthly minimum (historically around $280/month) that effectively sets a floor near 50 units. Stack tiers, add-ons (AI leasing, premium support, payments volume), and a 200-unit portfolio can run into five figures a year. Exact pricing isn't published as a flat rate card and has shifted over time, so get a current quote — but the order of magnitude is the point: AppFolio is a real line item in your operating budget, Innago is not.

What the price gap buys. Roughly: accounting depth, maintenance operations, AI leasing, owner/investor reporting, and support infrastructure. Whether that's worth $3,000–$10,000+/year depends entirely on portfolio size — see the verdict section.

Rent collection

Both handle the core job: tenants pay online via ACH, autopay is available, and late fees can be automated. The differences are in scale features.

Innago covers the DIY essentials: online rent payments, autopay enrollment, automatic late fees per your settings, and a clean payment ledger. ACH transfers typically take 3–5 business days. It's everything a small landlord needs and nothing they don't.

AppFolio adds the professional layer: bulk rent payment processing across hundreds of units, more payment method options, automated rent reminders at scale, and payment reporting that feeds directly into the accounting system. When you're collecting from 150 doors, the difference between "payments work" and "payments work with reconciliation, exceptions, and reporting built in" is a part-time employee's worth of labor.

Verdict: identical for a handful of units; AppFolio pulls ahead decisively past ~50 doors.

Tenant screening

Innago offers built-in screening with credit, background, and eviction history — paid by the applicant (around $30), which is the industry-standard arrangement and keeps your costs at zero. For a deeper look at what good screening looks like, see our tenant screening services compared.

AppFolio offers screening too, with more report configurations and deeper integration into the application workflow (screening criteria, automated decisioning support, adverse-action compliance tooling). For high-volume leasing — dozens of applications a week — that automation matters.

Verdict: both get the job done; AppFolio's edge is workflow automation at volume, not report quality.

Accounting: the biggest real gap

This is where the price difference shows up most.

Innago's accounting is basic but honest: income and expense tracking, simple reports, exportable data. It answers "did I make money this month?" For a landlord with a few units doing their own books (or handing a clean export to a CPA), it's sufficient.

AppFolio's accounting is a full property management accounting system: general ledger, bank reconciliation, automated owner distributions and statements, 1099 generation, trust accounting compliance, and budget-vs-actual reporting. If you have investor-owners expecting monthly statements, or a bookkeeper on staff, this is the category that justifies the subscription. Innago cannot do owner distributions or trust accounting — full stop.

If accounting is your main pain point but you're not ready for AppFolio's price tag, the middle path is pairing a free tool with dedicated bookkeeping software or landlord banking — our Baselane review covers the banking-plus-bookkeeping approach.

Verdict: AppFolio by a mile for anyone with owners, staff, or complex books; Innago is fine for simple DIY portfolios.

Maintenance

Innago gives tenants a maintenance request portal and gives you basic tracking — request in, status updates, request closed. For a landlord who handles repairs themselves or with one handyman, that's the whole workflow.

AppFolio runs a real maintenance operation: work orders with priority and assignment, vendor management with dispatch, maintenance coordination across a team, and cost tracking tied into accounting. If you have maintenance staff or a vendor roster, this is a different product category, not just a nicer version of the same thing.

Verdict: AppFolio for teams; Innago for DIY.

Leasing, marketing, and AI

Innago covers listings, online applications, and electronic lease signing — the complete DIY leasing flow, free. It does not do automated showings, chatbots, or AI.

AppFolio has invested heavily here, including an AI leasing assistant (Realm-X) that answers prospect inquiries, schedules showings, and nurtures leads around the clock. For managers leasing dozens of units a month, AI-handled inquiries are a genuine labor saver. Innago has no equivalent — you'll answer inquiries yourself.

Verdict: AppFolio if leasing volume justifies automation; otherwise a non-factor.

Who each one actually fits

Choose Innago if:

You own 1–20 units and self-manage (the sweet spot)
You want $0 software costs, period
Your accounting needs are "track income and expenses," not "produce owner statements"
You handle maintenance yourself or with a single handyman
You answer your own leasing inquiries

Choose AppFolio if:

You manage ~50+ units (the pricing minimums assume this scale)
You have investor-owners who need monthly statements and distributions
You run maintenance with staff or a vendor network
Your leasing volume justifies AI and automation
You need trust accounting compliance and 1099 handling

The awkward middle (20–50 units): this is the only range where the choice requires real thought. At 30 self-managed units with simple finances, Innago is still free and still works — many landlords in this range never outgrow it. The trigger to switch isn't unit count, it's complexity: the day you add a partner who needs statements, hire staff, or spend more time on bookkeeping than the software saves, AppFolio's fee starts paying for itself. Until that day, free wins.

There's also a middle path worth knowing: services like Hemlane offer leasing and management help without full AppFolio-scale software — see our Hemlane review if you're in that in-between zone.

Feature comparison table

Feature	Innago	AppFolio

Monthly cost to landlord	$0	Per-unit (~$1.50/unit/mo typical), monthly minimum

Unit minimum	None	Effectively ~50 units via pricing minimums

Online rent collection	Yes (ACH)	Yes (ACH + more options)

Autopay	Yes	Yes

Automatic late fees	Yes	Yes

Bulk payment processing	No	Yes

Tenant screening	Yes, applicant-paid	Yes, more configurations

Lease templates + e-sign	Yes	Yes

Online applications	Yes	Yes

AI leasing assistant	No	Yes

Income/expense tracking	Yes	Yes

General ledger + bank rec	No	Yes

Owner statements + distributions	No	Yes

1099 generation	No	Yes

Trust accounting	No	Yes

Maintenance request portal	Yes	Yes

Work orders + vendor dispatch	No	Yes

Owner/investor portal	No	Yes

Mobile app	Yes (basic)	Yes (full-featured)

Dedicated support/onboarding	Limited (free tier)	Yes

The verdict by portfolio size

1–10 units: Innago, no contest. AppFolio's minimums alone would cost you more per month than the software saves. Put the money toward your reserves instead.
10–25 units: Innago. Still free, still sufficient, unless your books are unusually complex.
25–50 units: Innago until complexity forces the switch. Watch for the triggers: partners needing statements, hired help, bookkeeping eating your weekends.
50–200 units: AppFolio territory. The per-unit cost dilutes, and the accounting, maintenance, and leasing automation earn their keep.
200+ units: AppFolio (or an enterprise alternative). Innago was never built for this.

The honest summary: Innago is the best free property management software for small landlords precisely because it doesn't pretend to be AppFolio. And AppFolio is worth its price precisely because it doesn't try to be free. Match the tool to the portfolio, and you'll never overpay in either direction.

Affiliate disclosure: This article may contain affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.